I am sorry that I did not make the criticism more balanced. I agree that many hymns are out to touch with modern thinking and can be very difficult, to sing. Traditionalists about hymns can be stuck on a false pride or sense of sophistication.

I do not think that replacing a poor organ music with poor praise music advances the chruch’s ministry. Whatever music we choose for worship needs to be done well. I was always shocked when soloist would sing for the church’s worship service without having practiced.

Let me be clear, there is time and place in worship for every form and style of music - after all - it all praises the One God.

Thanks for your comments!

Peace,

John

I like your posts! However, I would love to debate with you on this topic. A friend who is working on his D.Min. on postmodern ministry like to compare praise music with chanting from the MIddles Ages. There is a lot of repetition in both, and for a reason. Somestimes it takes time for the message to settle into our souls.

I agree with you about the quality of music can make or break the inspiration that comes through the music. You say you enjoy both, but only criticize poorly done praise music. Can you also write about inspiration from well-done praise music or poorly done organ/classical music?

There are a lot of poor praise bands, and a lot of great ones. One thing I like about praise music is how accessible it is for people to play on guitar without a lot of training (especially Chris Tomlin songs). This facilitates personal worship at home more easily than trying to play classical music.

Thanks for all your writing! Great job!!

Jeff